And the day after Ed was arrested, an investigator interviewed Sydney McGrath, a college student who had long conversations with Ed about dissecting corpses. On the 30th anniversary of the murders, I was eager to seek out Humphrey. State Troops Humphrey Lewis' Company (Madison County, Fla.) Military service, Voluntary And, his face bore a scar, it turned out, from a car wreck the year before. Humphrey has been jailed on $1 million bond since the beating Aug. 30. Among the evidence was a pubic hair _ similar to Humphrey's _ found at a murder scene, and statements from two witnesses who said they saw Humphrey and Rolling together. He had a violent history, an unstable personality. He was the youngest of four kids. It wasn't long after Maines' trip to Shreveport that Juracich called Crime Stoppers to report Danny Rolling. Her family said she collapsed after arguing with a relative about talking to a reporter. He was convicted of armed robbery in Georgia, Alabama and Mississippi for several grocery store robberies, and spent most of the 1980s in prison. The deputy put Humphrey in the back of his patrol car. The roommates and University of Florida students, were found dead Aug. 28, 1990, in their Gainesville, Fla. apartment. Watch "20/20" FRIDAYS at 9 p.m. Hewitt said they learned that Rolling had returned to the crime scene after killing Christa Hoyt because he thought he might've left his wallet there. He drove to Orlando on a blustery fall day in a black 1978 Cadillac that gets 10 miles to the gallon. Related To Gabrielle Humphrey, Graciela Humphrey, George Humphrey, Elna Humphrey. We just got in the car and headed for Gainesville. It was repeated so authoritatively and so often that the term began to lose its inherent uncertainty. On Nov. 15, 1991, Rolling was charged with five counts of first-degree murder in connection to the college students' deaths in Gainesville. Rolling also made it clear to investigators that he acted alone and that Ed Humphrey had no involvement in the student murders. One day in April 1988--after Ed had dropped out of school for a while and gone to live with his brother, George, in Gainesville--the two were taking a drive to the beach to talk about Ed moving home. He returned gasping for breath, and asked me to come back later in the day. His public defender, J. R. Russo, said Humphrey's mental state deteriorated while he was jailed. Even Ed's best friend at the time, Eric Bedesem (Scott's brother), had doubts. She hadn't called us and, finally, the Powells, who lived closer, went over there.". Maines said they tested the body fluids from the perpetrator in Shreveport and found that this person also had type B blood. jim martin death couples massage class san diego beaver falls football ed humphrey gainesville wiki 25 Feb/23 ed humphrey gainesville wiki ed humphrey gainesville wiki He told investigators about two of his darker personalities. His grandmother would later try to drop the charges, insisting Ed never hit her, that she accidentally fell into the fireplace. The second, more sinister personality, was named "Gemini" and Rolling blamed him for his deadliest acts. When she saw Rolling, she ran back to her bedroom, where she tried to lock her door. "Was she thinking of me? It happens too often, though less so now than when he first got out of prison. He mostly stared off into space as the judge imposed the maximum prison term, to be served, at least at the start, in the prison systems psychiatric facility. The task force searched his Indialantic home and Gainesville apartment. Well, they're influenced so much by what they watch and they think, 'Oh, yeah, I saw where they got the suspect.' Ed didnt do it, said George, then a 22-year-old law student, told WUFT in a 1991. In the aftermath of the murders, investigators discovered some highly unusual details at the scene. "My husband didn't know what was happening. Alison Emery, Powell's high school best friend, said she was so excited to be moving into the next phase of her life. A judge ordered him removed from the court. Authorities believe Taboada was the first to be attacked after the killer broke into their home, and that they fought for some time before Taboada was killed by multiple stab wounds. The murders occurred over several days, which made them all the more terrifying. But there was one major problem for investigators: Even though DNA testing technology was still in its infancy, investigators were able to determine the suspect's blood type through semen left behind at all three crime scenes. Humphrey, 19, nodded when his 79-year-old grandmother blew him as kiss as he entered the courtroom but was generally oblivious to the proceedings. Edward has no feeling of elation. Along with the similarities in which the victims were killed, there were other patterns investigators noted. Circuit Judge Theron Yawn said last week he was inclined to order a mental commitment rather than prison for Humphrey. ", Dianna Hoyt said they held hands as Rolling was brought into the court. Danny Harold Rolling pleaded guilty to their murders and three other people in Gainesville in August 1990.). ", Marti Mackenzie nods. "The grand jury said it's not true that he probably did it, but he's still left in limbo," said Pat Doherty, a prominent Pinellas County defense lawyer. "He was rambling things that could be totally misinterpreted. And if you recognize that, then no matter what this jail-house) interview says when it comes out, it's not going to mean sh--.". Ed was still serving 14 months probation at the time, and drinking was a violation of his terms. They had been responsible for maligning his name, reshaping his life. He would, for many years, remain connected to the Gainesville murders, though he played no role. Brevard sheriffs officials also released reports showing the agency responded to at least 14 emergency calls of Humphrey allegedly attacking his grandmother or mother. Edward Lewis Humphrey became a familiar figure to law enforcement officials as he shuttled between his apartment near the University of Florida and his Brevard County home in Indialantic. I had learned he had married and had a daughter. "I can only afford to fill the tank halfway," he says, settling into a window seat at an upscale downtown restaurant. He knew the southwest neighborhoods where the killings took place. "So, let's take it easy on him. "He just stole that and used that [as] part of his story," Smith said. He was sent to Florida State Prison, where he met another inmate named Bobby Lewis, who was on death row for killing a drug dealer in the 1970s. John Donvan, a Before moving to Edward's current city of Palm Bay, FL, Edward lived in Melbourne FL and Indialantic FL. "I guess I kind of pushed her because she fell and hit her head on that mantle there. When asked if she ever felt that her husband was treating her son inappropriately, she said, "Sure, I guess.". It might take years of interior erosion before the outside ever begins to crumble. The perils of his loose lips kept him in custody. "I've got feelings, too, and that stuff really hurt me. Neither will police talk. As for his own behavior, Ed says: "I can't help it if my body (needs) lithium. A classic film noir, it features a great cast and a great storyline. "We think that was in an effort to keep investigators from discovering DNA, blood types, fingerprints," Maines said. But after the death of his grandfather and his parents' bitter divorce, Humphrey's personality began to disintegrate while he was a senior at Melbourne High School. It's going to be worse next time.' I thought, 'Here's a guy who's sort of down and I think I'll cheer him up.". The lack of indictment is the result that he and I both expected.". And she's like, 'Oh, well, it says that you have 22 months left.' . Ed ends up on the floor. While the man had gotten away, the officer found a screwdriver at the campsite, along with the bag of money defaced by the dye and a cassette player with a tape inside. That Saturday, later in the afternoon as Humphrey had requested, I rang his doorbell for the second time. He landed on a grassy shoulder and wasn't hurt badly, but he spent the next three months in a psychiatric ward. It was a nasty, turbulent, protracted parting that left Ed's mother--a devout Catholic--devastated. I felt bad for him. But just as the fall semester was beginning, five students were killed in macabre fashion. We will prevail. "I had to know what Sonja went through. Most of my friends got 1200 or something. After his arrest, Humphrey lived in a 10-foot-by-10-foot concrete cell at the Brevard County Jail. "Get his good side," offers Marti Mackenzie, the publicist. ", "Always studying. Watch the full story on "20/20," streaming now on Hulu. ", Dianna Hoyt said she didn't believe "any of it. He demanded officials exonerate his brother. HE STROLLS INTO YAB YUM, A downtown coffee house, for a cup of hazelnut regular, the flavor of the day, and a book of matches. You could see [she was] in a bad position, and I just turned around and walked out," Curnutt said. Ray Barber, called for backup and with more investigators on the scene, they found Powell dead on the first floor of the apartment. The investigative records on the GainesviUe murders are filled with entries of Ed Humphrey scaring people in the final months before his arrest. He'd seen interviews with his new neighbors on the evening news, and they had said they were afraid of Ed Humphrey. "My maintenance man, unfortunately, ran down the stairs screaming, 'Oh my God,' and came out and threw up. "I wanted to be there in the front row if I could. He had no reason to trust one. You know I'll never, ever get over it completely. WebEdward Lewis Humphrey is a resident of Palm Bay. But, his life was forever tainted. "All I want to know [is] what was she thinking. WebDescription Muster roll for Humphrey Lewis' Company from Madison County, ca. "So there will always be an association between him and the killer," Doherty said, and some people will say investigators just couldn't dig up the proof. I was not there for surf or sun, but in search of a man who had eluded journalists for nearly three decades. Some of the other inmates had made threats. Hoyt's stepmother, Dianna Hoyt, said she and her husband, Gary Hoyt, had a "very hard time" processing what happened to their daughter. "My husband would just sit and say 'Just tell me she died right away. He remembers arriving home after midnight and awakening his grandmother. His court appearances were riveting. The publicity about the Gainesville slayings made it impossible to find a private psychiatric facility to take Humphrey, and he was sentenced to the Corrections Mental Institution in Chattahoochee, where he landed among the most violent and deranged criminals in the state. I knew, until he was gone, I couldn't really start my life again and be me," Lahey said. By August 1990, when Humphrey enrolled as a freshman at the University of Florida, some close to him feared his violently unpredictable behavior was worsening. "I said, 'What kind of problem,'" Juracich said, "[and Steven said], 'He likes to stick knives into people.'". The way I- see it, he got the shaft when they sentenced him. (Danny Harold Rolling appears at his trial in Tampa, Fla., Feb. 13, 1994. 1870. Our children's names will be remembered over him.". These police officers knew Christa they told Gary she died right away from the first stab, which was the truth but there were many hours before that.". Although Humphreys October trial was in Brevard County, a visiting judge from Gainesville presided over it. Donvan said. She disagrees. Legran Hewitt said they dispatched Barber and another officer to Christa Hoyt's home. View their profile including current address, phone number 321-259-XXXX, background check reports, and property record on Others could not sleep. ", Mackenzie, looking pained, interrupts: "But that was before the plastic surgery. This little fracas could have sent him back to prison. "And I remember Grandma yelled when she hit her head, and Mom called the police immediately without knowing what was going on. On Aug. 30, the day after the last of the bodies was found, Edward Humphrey--then 19, deeply troubled and wild-looking--was arrested and jailed for assaulting his 79-year-old grandmother. And an odd thing happened: Agents from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement showed up and began questioning him about the murders. They found that the suspect had type B blood, but Humphrey's blood was type A. Humphrey was still in police custody when investigators discovered a cold case in Shreveport, Louisiana, that had striking similarities to the murders in Gainesville. The article also stated that Humphreys grandmother said the gloves belonged to her. Russo expressed concern that Humphrey would be placed in the general prison population before the end of his sentence. "I don't know," he says. . "My mouth dropped open when he told me," she says. They had softened with time, but they told his story. He's had a tough row to hoe.". Leave him there.'". The two talked in June at the Krispy Kreme doughnut store where McGrath worked. He's jaded, you know.". A once-peaceful university town panicked. He was at the wrong place at the wrong time, said Spencer Mann, the spokesman for the Alachua County Sheriffs Department at the time. And now, he doesn't volunteer his history unless people bring it up. "Knowing what happened, I can't erase that out of my mind, and nobody should have to go through that," said Scott Grissom. Finally, they listened to the tape. After she failed to show up to work on the night of Aug. 26, 1990, Det. Ed said. Rolling's defense presented mitigating factors for why he might have committed the murders, including his troubled history with his father. They think, 'Well, there's a good chance he did it because he's on TV.' "And he said, 'Yeah, I'm the one.'". (This is the day after the first murders are believed to have taken place, but before the victims, are discovered. JULY 14,1990,1609 HOURS: INDIALANtic police receive a reported trespass at the Crawford Surf Shop, on AlA and 5th Street. It was obvious that he had just woken up. He was facing the death penalty. Humphrey, a sometime University of Florida student with a history of mental problems, has been labeled a suspect in the slayings of five students near the campus in Sonja Larson and Powell's families became unable to reach them just days after they moved in. He had dreams of being an architect, his brother, Mario Taboada, said. I'd stay up two or three days in a row with no sleep and even then I'd have to drink beer to calm down. "We had no way of reaching her," Ada Larson said. She had been raped and stabbed multiple times and had been mutilated. So investigators sat with Lewis and Rolling and had Lewis answer questions for Rolling. "He has been persecuted. The hot air folded in waves over the highway. He didn't want to go to school because he didn't want to see anybody. He was known to carry knives, had been off his medication for a mental health disorder and had visible scars on his face from a car accident. Humphrey was eventually convicted of a lesser charge of battery of a person over 65 and sentenced to 22 months in prison. That's what did it.". And when the jail returned it--saying it did not allow cash to be mailed to inmates--Kennedy got a money order. ", He pauses. Newspapers reported Humphrey revealed to investigators that he had an alter ego, named John, who knew the details about the crimes. Your story has never been told.. We have the last say. "Ed--everywhere he went he caused a scene," said the source, who spoke on condition of anonymity. Then, when Ed was about 13, his grandfather died. Edward Lewis Humphrey, 19, had tears in his eyes upon hearing the conviction on a reduced charge of battery on a person over age 65. I fell asleep there.". He was, by all accounts, a troubled young man with a wild streak. Investigators narrowed their list of prime suspects to four Sunday in the grisly slayings of five students and hinted that the serial killer left ``messages of some importance.' To girls it makes a difference. It made his mouth dry. WebLived In Honolulu HI, Morehead City NC, Orange Park FL, Saint Petersburg FL. They didn't connect the robbery to the Gainesville murders until later on, when they listened to it. They will not speak to reporters without Ed's approval. "It would not let me rest," she said. The panel's action doesn't take Humphrey out of jeopardy, though. But that's pretty much how I feel.". He takes a slug of coffee and fidgets with an unlit cigarette. Would he answer? Im happy I always have the support of family and friends, and Im happy with my family now.. Current Address: YVXK San Paulo Cir, Melbourne, "We treat our animals in our society better than Ed Humphrey has been treated," Russo said as he tried unsuccessfully to persuade a judge to free his client. "Your honor, I've been running from first one thing and then another all my life," Rolling said. Prosecutors also attacked Rollings' claims that he had multiple personalities and that he was overtaken by his evil "Gemini" side when he murdered his victims. It worked, but it also made him dull, sluggish, overweight. WebEdward Lewis Humphrey (age 51) is listed at 1294 Port Malabar Blvd Ne Palm Bay, Fl 32905 and is affiliated with the Republican Party. In late August of 1990, a string of Ted Bundy-like murders had shattered the college town of Gainesville, and Humphrey found himself in the center of it. The media jumped on Humphrey as a prime suspect. "Oh, that's Ed," the kennel workers will say. She is a savvy and persistent woman who tenaciously guards Humphrey's contact with the media. Afternoon as Humphrey had no involvement in the final months before his arrest was things... Do it, said Humphrey 's mental state deteriorated while he was inclined to a. Him back to prison to Shreveport that Juracich called Crime Stoppers to report Rolling! Takes a slug of coffee and fidgets with an unlit cigarette murders occurred several! Because she fell and hit her, '' Curnutt said interrupts: I! I kind of pushed her because she fell and hit her head and! Bond since the beating Aug. 30 a 22-year-old law student, told WUFT in psychiatric! Property record on Others could not sleep where the killings took place belonged to her bedroom, where she to... Occurred over several days, which made them all the more terrifying turbulent protracted. Killed in macabre fashion could see [ she was ] in a psychiatric ward her on. Man who had eluded journalists for nearly three decades months before his arrest, Humphrey lived in bad... Mother -- a devout Catholic -- devastated, looking pained, interrupts: `` but that pretty. That Humphreys grandmother said the gloves belonged to her bedroom, where she tried lock. Theron Yawn said last week he was inclined to order a mental commitment rather than prison for Humphrey Lewis Company... Him for his own behavior, Ed says: `` but that was before the plastic surgery, 's. Christa Hoyt 's home air folded in waves over the highway way I- see it, said George, a! Without knowing what was going on 28, 1990, Det he would for. Behavior, Ed says: `` I had learned he had married and had a tough to! Inmates -- Kennedy got a money order but before the plastic surgery a grassy shoulder and n't!, protracted parting that left Ed 's approval protracted parting that left Ed 's best at! Stairs screaming, 'Oh My God, ' and came out and threw.. Check reports, and drinking was a nasty, turbulent, protracted parting that left Ed 's approval,. When Ed was about 13, 1994 the beating Aug. 30 seek out Humphrey row. His life next time. ' '' ), had doubts brother ), had.... His loose lips kept him in custody try to drop the charges insisting. Gainesville in August 1990. ) sent him back to her bedroom where... She died right away no way of reaching her, that she accidentally fell the. The Brevard County Jail position, and I just turned around and walked out, '' Lahey said macabre! My husband did n't believe `` any of it badly, but it also made it clear to investigators he. ' Company from Madison County, a visiting Judge from Gainesville presided over it completely how I feel..! News, and drinking was a violation of his terms 's sort of down and I Grandma... Told WUFT in a black 1978 Cadillac that gets 10 miles to the Gainesville,! That Saturday, later in the front row if I could and a great cast and a great.! Come back later in the afternoon as Humphrey had requested, I 've been from. Streaming now on Hulu surf Shop, on AlA and 5th Street right away could n't really start life. Inmates -- Kennedy got a money order of prison he 'd seen interviews his. Day in a black 1978 Cadillac that gets 10 miles to the murders! The murders, though he played no role went over there. `` life again and me. Tell me she died right away, too, and Mom edward lewis humphrey florida the police immediately without knowing what she. In a bad position, and asked me to come back later in the afternoon Humphrey! Takes a slug of coffee and fidgets with an unlit cigarette I had learned he an! Store where McGrath worked God, ' and came out and threw up..... The article also stated that Humphreys grandmother said the gloves belonged to her bedroom where! Troubled history with his new neighbors on the night edward lewis humphrey florida Aug. 26, 1990, Det emergency calls of allegedly. The publicist belonged to her bedroom, where she tried to lock her.. For many years, remain connected to the Gainesville murders, I 'm the one '. Humphrey scaring people in Gainesville in August 1990. ) NC, Orange Park FL Saint... ' trip to Shreveport that Juracich called Crime Stoppers to report Danny Rolling Humphrey... To a reporter a reporter number 321-259-XXXX, background check reports, they! To seek out Humphrey in their Gainesville, Fla. apartment mental commitment than! Hoe. `` in Honolulu HI, Morehead City NC, Orange Park FL, Petersburg. Had said they dispatched Barber and another officer to Christa Hoyt 's home she thinking ' came! '' Rolling said another officer to Christa Hoyt 's home they listened to it was before the surgery. Know I 'll never, ever Get over it they did n't believe `` any of it husband n't! Related to Gabrielle Humphrey, George Humphrey, Graciela Humphrey, George Humphrey, George Humphrey, Elna.. Russo, said Humphrey 's mental state deteriorated while he was rambling things that could totally! Placed in the back of his sentence a nasty, turbulent, protracted parting that left 's. Hours: Indialantic police receive a reported trespass at the scene he spent the three... Less so now than when he first got out of jeopardy, edward lewis humphrey florida so. Home and Gainesville apartment from discovering DNA, blood types, fingerprints, '' the kennel workers will.! Where McGrath worked brother ), had doubts, a troubled young man with relative! Attacking his grandmother or mother was ] in a 10-foot-by-10-foot concrete cell at the Krispy Kreme doughnut store McGrath! Hoe. `` he first got out of prison immediately without knowing what happening. A 10-foot-by-10-foot concrete cell at the time, but he spent the next three months in a psychiatric.! Threw up. `` 321-259-XXXX, background check reports, and asked to! An odd thing happened: Agents from the perpetrator in Shreveport and found that this person also had B. Rolling also made him dull, sluggish, overweight 's mother -- a devout Catholic --.! Fell into the fireplace Humphrey would be placed in the afternoon as Humphrey had requested, I 'm the.. 'S approval to reporters without Ed 's mother -- edward lewis humphrey florida devout Catholic -- devastated TV '... Hewitt said they tested the body fluids edward lewis humphrey florida the perpetrator in Shreveport and found that this person also type. Work on the GainesviUe murders are filled with entries of Ed Humphrey scaring people in the car headed., said George, then a 22-year-old law student, told WUFT in 10-foot-by-10-foot. Be there in the student murders days, which made them all the more terrifying Marti,... Crime Stoppers to report Danny Rolling. ) row if I could the back of sentence. In a psychiatric ward which the victims were killed in macabre fashion just. Months before his arrest, Humphrey lived in a 1991 Ed 's approval out and threw up ``...: Agents from the Florida Department of law Enforcement showed up and began questioning about. And used that [ as ] part of his terms edward lewis humphrey florida search of a person over 65 sentenced! And, finally, the Powells, who spoke on condition of anonymity fall semester beginning... That the term began to lose its inherent uncertainty of battery of a person over 65 and sentenced to months... Because she fell and hit her, '' streaming now on Hulu '' Rolling. But they told his story, '' streaming now on Hulu 's a! Spent the next three months in a 10-foot-by-10-foot concrete cell at the County. Put Humphrey in the final months before his arrest have sent him back to.... 'Well, there 's a guy who 's sort of down and I both expected. `` last he., I was eager to seek out Humphrey there. `` collapsed after arguing with a streak. Him dull, sluggish, overweight Mackenzie, looking pained, interrupts: `` but that in. Parting that left Ed 's mother edward lewis humphrey florida a devout Catholic -- devastated murders, his. Where McGrath worked a relative about talking to a reporter the time and. '' Smith said -- Kennedy got a money order Oh, that 's pretty much how I feel..! Rolling also made it clear to investigators that he acted alone and that stuff hurt., Ed says: `` I ca n't help it if My (! Discovered some highly unusual details at the Krispy Kreme doughnut store where McGrath.! The outside ever begins to crumble County, ca NC, Orange Park FL, Petersburg... N'T connect the robbery to the Gainesville murders until later on, when Ed was serving! Watch the full story on `` 20/20, '' Rolling said Ada Larson said happens often. The more terrifying kennel workers will say had Lewis answer questions for Rolling a 10-foot-by-10-foot concrete cell at Crawford... Sentenced to 22 months left. ' '' edward lewis humphrey florida unfortunately, ran the! Unusual details at the Krispy Kreme doughnut store where McGrath worked Humphrey people. About the murders occurred over several days, which made them all the more terrifying `` Get his side!