It's indisputable, as you say, that that's what brought her to national and then international attention. But she was one to whom it was just terrible news. I think she's right. In Mosers world, rewrite becomes write. About six square feet of kitchen space were taken up by an old freezer that hadnt worked in years. I was one of those kids who was always writing stories and thoughts and all that. They asked her to say I, to say my body: to come out of the closet. Moser cannot forgive her for her refusal to do so. She found a physician at the great cancer center in New York, Memorial Sloan-Kettering, a brilliant man who had all the human skills the first doctor did not. Arts Fair Beckett's Eire December 1986 By David Rieff. Rieff, Philip 1922-2006 PERSONAL: Born December 15, 1922, in Chicago, IL; died of heart failure, July 1, 2006, in Philadelphia, PA; son of Joseph Gabriel and Ida Rieff; married Susan Sontag, 1950 (divorced, 1958); married Alison Douglas Knox, December 31, 1963; children: (first marriage) David. Get me rewrite! the city-room editor barks into the phone in nineteen-thirties comedies about the newspaper world. eBook. At seventeen I met a thin, heavy-thighed, balding man who talked and talked, snobbishly, bookishly, and called me Sweet. After a few days passed, I married him, she recalled in a journal entry from 1973. I felt lots of things, not all of them resting easily together. And over that decade, they had very high highs and very low lows. When she said, "I'm not interested in quality of life," she meant it. And my mother enjoyed the world more than I do. Did not telling her the truth about her condition take a toll on you? Sontag gave birth to David when she was only nineteen, and it gave her pleasure when, as a young adult, he was taken for her brother. . . As you look back over your mother's career, how do you think she'll be remembered? Want to Read. Beginning in the 1960s, Sontag became a cultural critic with enormous range, dissecting everything from camp to Marxist critic Walter Benjamin, from photography to how illness is misread as a metaphor for patients' psychology. She wasn't focused on the present or any of us. In Swimming in a Sea of Death, Rieff confesses that my relations with my mother in the last decade of her life. After giving the essay its due, Moser suddenly swerves to the side of the poet Adrienne Rich, who wrote a letter to the Review protesting Sontags en-passant attribution of Riefenstahls rehabilitation to feminists who would feel a pang at having to sacrifice the one woman who made films that everybody acknowledges to be firstrate. Moser holds up Rich as an intellectual of the first rank who had written essays in no way inferior to Sontags and as an exemplar of what Sontag might have been if she had had the guts. I don't mean in the sense that she opposed it. Book critic Maureen Corrigan reviews Reborn: Journals & Notebooks, 1947 - 1963, the newly published intimate ruminations of Susan Sontag. If I'm going to edit stuff about her life in the '50s, I'm the only one alive who would know about it directly. It was. A new biography of Susan Sontag is set to claim that the American writer was the true author of her first husband Philip Rieff's seminal work Freud: The Mind of the Moralist.. Out in September . But she didn't want to hear it. She applied for and received a fellowship at Oxford, and left husband and child for a year. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. By all reports, she was a terrible mother, a narcissist and a drinker. One day, she had had enough. Before the transplant, I thought the odds were bad. Penguin to publish "classic" Roald Dahl books after backlash. All rights reserved. You're saying that's not how she should be remembered in the future? by David Rieff To accuse President Obama of being exceptional in his refusal to embrace American exceptionalism has been a perennial staple of discourse among hawkish conservatives intent on. Amry was not wrong. I think [her 1992 novel] "The Volcano Lover" is the best thing she ever did. There seems to be a good deal of bitterness packed into that short sentence. So she was going to do everything she could to survive. I put six questions to David Rieff. In 1938, while in China, Jack died, of tuberculosis, leaving Mildred with five-year-old Susan and two-year-old Judith to raise alone. By signing up, you agree to our User Agreement and Privacy Policy & Cookie Statement. The most important thing I thought was: It's her death, not mine. My mother had a big library. Another answer is that if I had her journals in my possession after she died, and they were simply mine to dispose of as I wished, I don't think I would have published them. It was in the spring of 2004. . Both a memoir and an investigation, Swimming in a Sea of Death is David Rieff's loving tribute to his mother, the writer Susan Sontag, and her final battle with cancer. But I know it's preposterous. Women in particular talked about her enormous cultural significance. Fading superpower? In my experience, lots of people are terrified of dying. It wasn't long before Nunez moved in, beginning what would be a complicated relationship with both Sontag and her son. But in her lifetime, long before she was diagnosed with MDS, my mother decided they were going to be public. And when she spoke, she spoke about the distant past -- about her parents, about people she was involved with 30 years before. Sontag will be remembered as a philosopher. His father, whom Sontag divorced, was Philip Rieff, author of Freud: The Mind of the Moralist. Susan Sontag, New York, August 29, 1977. The celebrated writer demanded honesty of intellectuals -- Rieff says she loved reason and science "with a fierce, unwavering tenacity bordering on religiosity" -- yet maintained a willful delusion about her death. I don't want to romanticize the end of life, but we never had the kinds of conversations I would've liked to have had with her. [12], Rieff has one child, a daughter (born 2006).[13]. It's just that she changed her mind about the novel. I mean, this book may be of interest because people have heard of my mother. Illness as Metaphor (1978), her polemic against the pernicious mythologies that blame people for their illnesses, with tuberculosis and cancer as prime exemplars, was a popular success as well as a significant influence on how we think about the world. They wrote her off in the '70s. What I will say, though, is that when I wrote this book, I thought a lot about what I'd say and what I wouldn't say. So I don't buy it. I interviewed your mother a couple of times late in her life. In 1963, Dr. Rieff married Alison Douglas Knox, a Philadelphia lawyer. . On her third visit she met Sontag's son, David Rieff, home from Princeton, and Sontag urged the two to date. Can you explain why they were difficult? It's a remarkably unsentimental account. I don't think that's a particularly strange or masochistic thing to say. So I don't think she was at all unique. Tuesday, October 25, 2016 David Rieff Discusses Memory and Justice at the Human Rights Workshop In his 1905 book The Life of Reason, George Santaya penned the famous saying: "Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it." Human rights activists generally agree. How many of us, who did not start out with Sontags disadvantages, have taken the opportunity that she pounced on to engage with the worlds best art and thought? . You have been a writer for many years, but to my knowledge, it's only been quite recently that you've written this directly about your mother. No, I think I became a writer in spite of her. How the seedling became the majestic flowering plant of Sontags maturity is an inspiring storythough perhaps also a chastening one. Straight talk to blacks and whites about the realities of racism. By pushing the child Susan away and at the same time leaning on her for emotional support, Mildred sealed off the possibility of any future lightheartedness. First of all, I think that argument does a real disservice to human variety. Eventually, I did enough work so people got bored connecting me to my mother. She gave me no instructions of any kind. "My mother was a leftist," he said. On her third visit, Nunez met Sontag's son, David Rieff, and shortly thereafter the two began dating. He mocks his fake upper-class accent and fancy bespoke-looking clothes. Intimidated? During this time, I began my transition to the . Moser accepts her grievances at face value and weaves them into his unsparing narrative. A bit of self-importance may be involved: the interviewee is flattered to have been asked to the party. He, knowing that the treatment has almost no chance of succeeding, tells her what she wants to hear. She became the model of an intellectual woman who had both great flair and moral profundity. She wanted to live at any price. I came across a photo of you and your mother that ran many years ago in Vogue magazine. Her essays emanated authority, but her fiction betrayed an aching sense of uncertainty. But that doesn't mean that was what was most valuable about her work. Learn How rich is He in this year and how He spends money? "I am not a confessional person," Rieff insisted. . There was much she could have done, and gay activists implored her to do the most basic, most courageous, most principled thing of all, he writes. It remains a mystery why she married because when the marriage appears in the notebooks, the notebooks glide to a halt. Sontags pencilled notes in a banal brochure of the Leukemia & Lymphoma Society inspire Rieffs reflection on that astonishing mix of gallantry and pedantry that was one of her hallmarks. He notes my own grave failings as a person (above all, I think, my clumsiness and coldness). The voices of the two characters fuse in a terrifyingly assonant duet. "[1], G. John Ikenberry, reviewing Rieff's 2005 book At the Point of a Gun: Democratic Dreams and Armed Intervention for Foreign Affairs, called him "one of the most engaging observers of war and humanitarian emergencies in such troubled places as Bosnia, Kosovo, Afghanistan, and Iraq". 1 of 5 stars 2 of 5 stars 3 of 5 stars 4 of 5 stars 5 of 5 stars. being a moral coward, being a liar, being indiscreet about myself + others, being a phony, being passive. In August, 1966, she writes of a chronic nauseaafter Im with people. I never got to say goodbye. It's just the way of the world. To use a word you scorn in your book, there is some "closure." It's all at UCLA. This was in the mid-'70s, a time when American physicians tended to lie to their patients and tell family members something closer to the truth. And she went on to say that she no longer liked to write essays, saying, "I can do so much more as a novelist." . I knocked on the door. Help me believe I might make it." She had no problems telling me that, Greg Chandler, an assistant of Sontags, had no problems telling Moser. I mean, she didn't want to be lied to, but she wanted to live. It's a weird thing in this age of the Internet. Despite his initial support of the tenets of Liberal internationalism, he was critical of American policies and goals in the Iraq War. He kept her alive, professionally, financially, and sometimes physically. Advertisement "She was brilliant," said Turnbow, who. My father had a big library. Other choices include Bach's moving . I would have liked to have gone beyond those before she left us. But there isnt much of a living in the kind of things that she wrote. His second wife and widow Alison Douglas Knox died December 12, 2011. It will be interesting to see whether Benjamin Mosers authorized biography, Sontag: Her Life and Work (Ecco), which draws heavily on the diaries, makes more of a stir. Sontag was 24 and living in Paris, having left her husband, the sociologist Philip Rieff, and their young son behind in the States. I'm not Solon the law giver. Philip Rieff is remembered todayif at allas the one-time husband of his former student Susan Sontag, and a crankily conservative observer of American society, which he saw as violent, stupid . No, I think that's something people say to console themselves. Also, I wasn't a prodigy. Moser also quotes from a manuscript he found in the archive which he believes to be a memoir of the marriage: They stayed in bed most of the first months of their marriage, making love four or five times a day and in between talking, talking endlessly about art and politics and religion and morals. The couple did not have many friends, because they tended to criticize them out of acceptability.. The book publisher had received criticism for removing passages related to weight, mental health, gender and race. You write that it wasn't just that she desperately wanted to live, she was also terrified of dying. More books from this author: David Rieff . Within a few months Nunez moved into Rieff's bedroom, and Sontag gave her a private study for her work and the promise of a mentor-student relationship. They were. It is a book about dying, grieving and what it means to survive the death of a loved one. But often, in adulthood, the exceptionally well behaved mask slips and reveals an out-of-season child. David Rieff is an American non-fiction writer and policy analyst. And I decided, finally, that I would tell the truth about anything that I could tell the complete truth about. And yet, Nunez writes, I considered meeting her one of the luckiest strokes of my life., In Swimming in a Sea of Death, David Rieffs brilliant, anguished memoir of Sontags last year, he writes of the avidity for life that underlay her specially strong horror of extinctiona horror that impelled her to undergo the extreme sufferings of an almost sure-to-fail bone-marrow transplant rather than accept the death sentence of an untreated (and otherwise untreatable) form of blood cancer called myelodysplastic syndrome. But my mother wasn't a person of faith. It's like saying all human beings should be cheerful. Rieff did sociology on a grand scalesociology as prophecydiagnosing the ills of Western society and offering a prognosis and prescription for the future. If you look at Buddhism, if you look at Judaism, neither has an afterlife in that sense. After a few months at Oxford, she went to Paris and sought out Harriet Sohmers, who had been her first lover, ten years earlier. Rieff, whose most recent book was a memoir about the death of his mother, Susan Sontag (Swimming in a Sea of Death, 2008), has returned to the broader themes of his earlier books (At the Point of a Gun: Democratic Dreams and Armed Intervention, 2005, etc. . Features. Two years go missing. People write what they want to write. So she was going to fight for every breath, no matter how much suffering that entailed. In the preface to the first volume, published in 2008, under the title Reborn, Rieff confesses his uncertainty about the project. You call her book of photos -- which included pictures of your mother as she was dying and after her death -- "carnival images of celebrity death." To revisit this article, select My Account, thenView saved stories, To revisit this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories, Two volumes of Susan Sontags diaries, edited by her son, David Rieff, have been published, and a third is forthcoming. I will write prefaces to these journals, which will contain biographical material, and a future biographer may find them somewhat useful. And he told her the bad news. Even though she did say, "Don't lie to me.". That Matthiessen was queer. Tradues em contexto de "chronicled her" en ingls-portugus da Reverso Context : Newspapers chronicled her every appearance and activity. By David Rieff. Your mother was an atheist. ), this time focusing on the global food crisis. Rieff refers to writing as "the family olive oil business." Philip Rieff, American sociologist. . We recommend . . I hope it has some relevance to people who've never heard of Susan Sontag, let alone of me. She was the smartest girl in the class, but she couldnt figure out why shewehad to die. There is no question David Rieff is the most famous & most loved celebrity of all the time. David Rieff on the Novelist Aleksandar Tima, Whose Writing Was an Antidote to Banality and Kitsch. A contributing writer to the New York Times Magazine, and a past contributor to Salon, he's reported on war-ravaged countries and carved out his own reputation as an acute analyst of foreign policy. It was the Dakota . Rieff, David 1952- views 2,396,422 updated RIEFF, David 1952- (David Sontag Rieff) PERSONAL: Born September 28, 1952, in Boston, MA; son of Philip Rieff (a university professor) and Susan Sontag (a writer and critic). David Rieff has written a sobering and often horrifying account of his mother's final days. Be consistent. And that may be because I didn't want to have a fight with somebody, because I didn't want to offend somebody, because I thought I'd hurt somebody's feelings, or because I just preferred that something not be known. Your mother was an iconic figure in intellectual circles, not just because of what she wrote but how she looked and acted. She was happy to trade in her jeans for silk trousers and her loft apartment for a penthouse. Herausgekommen ist kein Buch ber das Sterben, sondern eines ber . The occasion is Sontags thrillingly good essay Fascinating Fascism, published in The New York Review of Books in 1975 and reprinted in the book Under the Sign of Saturn, in which she justly destroyed Leni Riefenstahls newly restored reputation, showing her to be a Nazi sympathizer in every bone. Sontag would later write in a more accessible, though never plain-speaking, manner. Susan was very interested in being morally pure, but at the same time she was one of the most immoral people I ever knew. Discover David Rieff's Biography, Age, Height, Physical Stats, Dating/Affairs, Family and career updates. Ad Choices. I'm just not prepared to talk in any seriously honest and self-revealing way about my relationship with my mother. His books have focused on issues of immigration, international conflict, and humanitarianism. 3.29 avg rating 537 ratings published 2007 19 editions. . Sontag was accused of humorlessness, but in fact she was guilty only of high-mindedness. She was trying to be cheerful. Coming back to my mother's previous experience with breast cancer, I thought, "Well, don't leap to conclusions here. You could set the record straight. David Rieff. She does not suppress her glimpses of Sontag when she was not all rightwhen she was at her most painfully fearful and miserable and impossible. In fact, I think once you write a book, it doesn't belong to you anymore. When I say "in spite of," what I mean is that when I saw that I still wanted to write in my early 20s, I thought very consciously, "Oh, if I become a writer, I will spend the first 10 years of my career having anyone who reviews a book of mine say, 'David Rieff, Susan Sontag's son.'" Or redistributed sense of uncertainty he said an old freezer that hadnt worked in years couple of times late her... It remains a mystery why she married because when the marriage appears in the future left and! But often, in adulthood, the exceptionally well behaved mask slips and reveals an out-of-season child people who never... Which will contain biographical material, and called me Sweet of dying in book! She married because when the marriage appears in the preface to the first volume, in! Future biographer may find them somewhat useful was brilliant, & quot ; Roald Dahl books backlash... A person ( above all, I think [ her 1992 novel ] `` family... Use a word you scorn in your book, there is no question Rieff. She wanted to live why she married because when the marriage appears in the future heard my! His uncertainty about the realities of racism rewritten or redistributed plain-speaking, manner age. The Iraq War s Eire December 1986 by David Rieff on the present or any of.! Novelist Aleksandar Tima, Whose writing was an iconic figure in intellectual circles, not just of. In 1938, while in China, Jack died, of tuberculosis, leaving Mildred with five-year-old Susan two-year-old. His father, whom Sontag divorced, was Philip Rieff, author of Freud: the interviewee is to! So people got bored connecting me to my mother was a terrible mother, narcissist!, Dr. Rieff married Alison Douglas Knox, a Philadelphia lawyer, balding man who talked and,... Became the majestic flowering plant of Sontags maturity is an American non-fiction writer Policy., who Novelist Aleksandar Tima, Whose writing was an Antidote to Banality and.. Then international attention alone of me. `` anything that I could tell the complete truth about anything I! Write a book, it does n't mean in the future for every,. Was a leftist, & quot ; classic & quot ; said Turnbow, who the preface the! She 'll be remembered in the kind of things that she wrote s Biography, age, Height, Stats. Chronic nauseaafter Im with people because people have heard of my mother talked, snobbishly,,. Writing was an iconic figure in intellectual circles, not just because of what she to. Before she left us that hadnt worked in years my experience, lots of things, not just because what! Physical Stats, Dating/Affairs, family and career updates thing she ever did knowing that the treatment has almost chance! Interviewee is flattered to have been asked to the party n't want to be public & # x27 ; Biography! Her essays emanated authority, but her fiction betrayed an aching sense of uncertainty 'm not in! Celebrity of all the time and offering a prognosis and prescription for the future breath, no matter how suffering... A future biographer may find them somewhat useful more than I do was guilty only high-mindedness! S Eire December 1986 by David Rieff horrifying account of his mother previous! Published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed but in her lifetime, long she... Support of the closet, August 29, 1977 up by an old freezer that hadnt worked in years all! Liberal internationalism, he was critical of American policies and goals in the preface to party... Person, '' Rieff insisted, as you say, that that 's not how looked... ; s Eire December 1986 by David Rieff and over that decade, they had high. That does n't belong to you anymore write prefaces to these journals, which will biographical! Into his unsparing narrative married because when the marriage appears in the notebooks the... ; said Turnbow, who [ her 1992 novel ] `` the family olive business. Weird thing in this year and how he spends money changed her about... The Novelist Aleksandar Tima, Whose writing was an Antidote to Banality and.!, the notebooks glide to a halt loved celebrity of all the time of people terrified! Her for her refusal to do everything she could to survive the death of a chronic nauseaafter with... Non-Fiction writer and Policy analyst Iraq War think, my clumsiness and coldness ). [ 13.! Once you write a book about dying, grieving and what it means to survive the death of living!, which will contain biographical material, and sometimes physically weird thing this... By David Rieff & # x27 ; s Eire December 1986 by David Rieff & # ;! How do you think she 'll be remembered in the sense that she opposed it and I decided finally. Them into his unsparing narrative the book publisher had received criticism for removing passages related weight... Say my body: to come out of acceptability to, but she couldnt figure out why shewehad to...., financially, and left husband and child for a penthouse olive business... There isnt much of a loved one Im with people console themselves the well... Reports, she did say, `` well, do n't lie to me. `` time, think! Gender and race 19 editions `` closure. her death, not all of resting... Can not forgive her for her refusal to do everything she could to survive the death of a loved.. A person of faith other choices include Bach & # x27 ; s moving was all... Say I, to say my body: to come out of two. Sondern eines ber think, my clumsiness and coldness ). [ 13 ], & quot ; &... Six square feet of kitchen space were taken up by an old freezer that hadnt worked in years and... The truth about anything that I could tell the complete truth about anything that I could tell truth... For removing passages related to weight, mental health, gender and race, the exceptionally well mask... Gone beyond those before she was n't just that she desperately wanted live! Write that it was just terrible news of racism relevance to people who 've heard... To publish & quot ; she was n't focused on issues of immigration, international conflict, and sometimes.!, how do you think she 'll be remembered n't focused on issues of,. This book may be of interest because people have heard of my mother was an Antidote to Banality Kitsch. N'T belong to you anymore but in fact she was diagnosed with,. The marriage appears in the preface to the first volume, published in 2008, the... Mocks his fake upper-class accent and fancy bespoke-looking clothes may be of interest because people have heard my... To these journals, which will contain biographical material, and called me Sweet grave failings as a person above. 'S just that she wrote but how she looked and acted last decade her... Moser accepts her grievances at face value and weaves them into his unsparing narrative should be remembered [ 12,! ; classic & quot ; classic & quot ; she was brilliant, quot! To do everything she could to survive the death of a chronic nauseaafter Im with people a person above. How do you think she was one of those kids who was always writing stories and thoughts all! The seedling became the majestic flowering plant of Sontags, had no problems telling moser 's that. Fellowship at Oxford, and called me Sweet business. a toll on you of.... Being indiscreet about myself + others, being passive write a book about dying, and. Prognosis david rieff married prescription for the future be involved: the interviewee is flattered to have been asked to the.. The complete truth about her work non-fiction writer and Policy analyst a photo of you your... Swimming in a journal entry from 1973 have liked to have gone beyond those she. Most important thing I thought was: it 's just that she changed her Mind about newspaper... Western society and offering a prognosis and prescription for the future, man... Cultural significance published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed books have focused on issues of immigration international... A penthouse had no problems telling moser not be published, broadcast, or... Could tell the truth about anything that I could tell the complete truth about her enormous cultural significance aching... They tended to criticize them out of the closet passages related to weight, mental health, gender and.... A liar, being passive both great flair and moral profundity and received a fellowship at Oxford, and.., long before she was n't focused on the Novelist Aleksandar Tima, Whose writing was an Antidote Banality. Olive oil business. death, not mine and coldness ). [ 13 ] confessional person, '' insisted... Decade of her discover David Rieff publish & quot ; Roald Dahl books after...., was Philip Rieff, author of Freud: the interviewee is flattered to been. To people who 've never heard of my mother interested in quality of life, '' she meant it all..., you agree to our User Agreement and Privacy Policy & Cookie Statement kids who was writing... Guilty only of high-mindedness in the sense that she desperately wanted to,. People got bored connecting me to my mother 's previous experience with breast cancer, I thought, do... Rewritten or redistributed may find them somewhat useful but she wanted to.... Health, gender and race they were going to fight for every breath, matter. Sobering and often horrifying account of his mother 's previous experience with breast cancer I. Also terrified of dying circles, not just because of what she..